You Tried to Expense What? The Strangest Tax Deductions CPAs Have Seen

In another lifetime, I worked for a publishing company whose accounts payable department was under the watch of a dour and intimidating woman I will simply call Jean. 

To this day, I contend that her previous position must have been as a prison matron at some correctional facility for incorrigibles. 

In any event, you walked on proverbial eggshells when you entered her office with a question about an expense. I was once taken to task for submitting a $6 invoice for a pain reliever after suffering a sudden migraine while attending a conference. On another occasion, she caught an employee rifling through her desk looking for his expense submissions. That afternoon, he became an ex-employee. 

Perhaps her most memorable performance came when she discovered that an administrator had attempted to disguise the purchase of a fur coat as “physical therapy.” 

I kid you not. 

The language directed at the perpetrator would have made a longshoreman blush. 

But I digress. 

As another harried tax season winds down, I find myself thinking about Jean and wondering how she might react to some of the more unusual deductions clients have tried to push through their accountants. 

Some unusual deductions may actually be legitimate. Others can quickly attract scrutiny from the IRS. 

For CPAs and accounting professionals, knowing the difference is critical. 

Strange But Legal Tax Deductions 

Some deductions sound so unusual that they hardly seem possible. Yet the tax code contains provisions that can produce surprising results when very specific requirements are met. 

For example, qualifying Native American whaling captains may be able to claim up to $10,000 for certain ship repair costs. 

In Hawaii, taxpayers with a qualifying Norfolk Pine may be permitted to deduct certain costs associated with its care and maintenance. 

There are also circumstances in which legal fees associated with criminal proceedings may qualify for a deduction, depending on the nature of the expense and the applicable tax rules. 

These examples underscore an important reality for tax professionals: the tax code contains highly specific provisions that can surprise even experienced CPAs. 

The lesson is not that every unusual expense is deductible. It is that unusual does not automatically mean impermissible. 

But These Were Quickly Flagged 

Then there are the expenses that make an accountant stop and ask, “You tried to expense what?” 

Consider the owner of a money-losing furniture store who paid an arsonist to burn down the business, reported the insurance proceeds as income, and attempted to deduct the payment to the arsonist as a “consulting fee.” 

An audit uncovered the scheme. 

Another taxpayer built a fallout shelter and classified the expense as “preventive medicine.” That deduction did not survive scrutiny either. 

And perhaps one of the strangest examples involved an ancient Samoan medical treatment consisting of prayers, massages, and plant leaves. The treatment was ultimately ruled nondeductible. 

Then there was the fur coat. 

An administrator at a publishing company attempted to classify the purchase of a fur coat as “physical therapy.” 

Jean did not approve. 

Neither would most accountants. 

What CPAs Can Learn From Unusual Expense Claims 

These examples are entertaining, but they also highlight a serious responsibility for CPAs and accounting firms. 

Questionable deductions are not simply a curiosity. They can create significant problems for both the taxpayer and the professional preparing the return. 

A strong review process should include: 

  • Thorough client intake and documentation review before filing. 
  • Clear communication with clients about what constitutes a legitimate business expense. 
  • Proactive audit-risk assessment, particularly when a client presents unusual or poorly documented deductions. 
  • Proper documentation supporting the business purpose and tax treatment of expenses. 

The key is to distinguish legitimate tax planning from an unsupported or inaccurate deduction. 

A client may believe an expense should be deductible. That does not make it so. 

What Should a CPA Do When a Client Pushes the Line? 

If a client insists on claiming a questionable deduction, the CPA should explain the potential risks and the basis for the tax treatment. 

The client’s request and the professional’s response should be appropriately documented. If an expense lacks a reasonable legal or factual basis, a CPA should not simply include it because the client insists. 

And if a client continues to demand treatment that the CPA cannot support, the professional may need to reconsider the engagement altogether. 

Protecting the client is important. Protecting the integrity of the firm’s work is equally important. 

The Bottom Line 

Tax professionals see plenty of unusual expenses. Some are legitimate. Some are misunderstandings. And occasionally, someone tries to pass off a fur coat as physical therapy. 

The strangest deductions can make for good stories, but they also serve as a reminder of why careful review matters. 

The best CPAs know that their role is not simply to find deductions. It is to help clients understand the rules, identify legitimate opportunities, and avoid unnecessary risk. 

Jean may have been intimidating, but perhaps she was onto something. 

She understood that every expense deserves a second look.